Kalshi, the federally regulated prediction market exchange, is set to appear before a New York state court on Monday, November 23, 2026, in a hearing that the company warns could force its entire exchange to shut down for users across the country, not just in New York. The case pits a Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)-licensed marketplace against state gambling enforcement in a jurisdictional dispute with no clear precedent.
The hearing is scheduled for 11:30 AM ET on November 23 before Justice Melissa Crane of the New York County Supreme Court. At issue is a temporary restraining order sought by New York Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul, who sued KalshiEX LLC on July 31, 2026, alleging the company operates an unlicensed gambling platform in violation of state gaming laws.
Why New York says Kalshi is gambling, not trading
The New York AG’s office contends that Kalshi allowed users aged 18 to 20 to open accounts and trade, below the state’s 21-year minimum for mobile sports betting. The state also alleges Kalshi operated without a New York State Gaming Commission license and evaded applicable taxes. Attorney General James said in the official press release that “prediction markets like Kalshi are gambling platforms, plain and simple.” For related coverage, see Bitcoin Faces Fed Test Sept. 16 as Core Inflation….
The enforcement action did not begin with the July lawsuit. New York’s Gaming Commission issued a cease-and-desist order to Kalshi in October 2025, more than a year before Monday’s hearing, according to the AG’s press release. New York alleges Kalshi did not comply, citing that alleged noncompliance as a basis for the lawsuit and requested restraining order. Context on this theme: Anthropic IPO Falters: Crypto Stocks & Mining US Session Roundup.
Kalshi says the order’s wording would shut down every user, everywhere
Kalshi’s core legal objection is not simply that the order is wrong, but that the specific language the AG has proposed would go far beyond New York. Attorney Sean Murphy of Milbank, representing Kalshi, warned that an order barring operations “within or from New York” would, according to The Block’s reporting, “shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere” and would “likely force the liquidation of all open positions.” Background reading: Wrapped Monero Token Falls 99% After Reported $13M Wallet Compromise.
That framing reflects Kalshi’s legal argument rather than an established legal conclusion. Kalshi argues that a prohibition on activity originating “from” the state would effectively be a nationwide kill switch. Murphy’s argument is not that New York lacks some authority; it is that the proposed remedy is disproportionate in its geographic reach.
Legal analyst Daniel Wallach flagged the potential escalation path. If Justice Crane adopts the “from New York” language in the restraining order, Wallach warned, “the next stop could be the U.S. Supreme Court’s emergency docket,” according to The Block’s coverage of the pre-hearing filings.
Federal courts declined to block New York
Kalshi and the CFTC both tried to keep the case in federal court, and both failed. Federal Judge Vernon Broderick remanded the dispute back to the New York County Supreme Court on November 19, 2026, ruling that prediction markets are not automatically exempt from state jurisdiction under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), according to ABC News. That ruling rejected Kalshi’s CEA preemption argument, at least at the preliminary stage.
New York is not acting alone against prediction markets
Kalshi is not the only target of New York’s enforcement push. The AG filed a similar enforcement action against Polymarket US (QCX LLC) on September 24, 2026, according to a separate NY AG court filing. The parallel actions suggest a coordinated state strategy against the prediction market sector broadly, not a dispute specific to Kalshi’s conduct or structure.
That pattern matters for the industry beyond Monday’s outcome. If Justice Crane issues the restraining order using the “from New York” language, the precedent could expose other CFTC-regulated exchanges operating from New York to similar state gaming enforcement, regardless of their federal licensing status. The same logic that New York applies to Kalshi could, in theory, be applied to any federally regulated market operator physically located in the state.
The prediction market’s own users and open positions may be the most immediate casualty of the jurisdictional fight, regardless of which side ultimately prevails on the law.
What to watch after Monday’s hearing
The immediate question on November 23 is whether Justice Crane grants the temporary restraining order and, critically, what language she uses to define its geographic scope. A narrowly worded order restricted to New York users would have a more limited geographic scope. Kalshi argues that an order covering operations originating “from” New York could have broader operational implications because it would affect every customer.
If Kalshi seeks emergency appellate relief at the state level and that fails, the Supreme Court’s emergency docket becomes the next option, as Wallach’s analysis suggests.
Investors and traders with open positions on Kalshi should watch for any court order issued after the 11:30 AM ET hearing. The company’s public statements and any CFTC emergency filings in the hours after the ruling will indicate whether a nationwide operational pause is imminent or whether Kalshi has obtained enough procedural breathing room to continue operating while the jurisdictional fight plays out in higher courts. The parallel enforcement action against Polymarket US means the outcome of Monday’s hearing will shape the regulatory outlook for the entire prediction market and crypto exchange sector heading into the final weeks of 2026.